16 Toys That Were Worth Every Penny of Your Allowance

Remember the thrill of saving up your allowance and finally getting your hands on that toy you’d been eyeing? Some toys were so worth it, they practically became legends in the world of childhood memories. Here’s a nostalgic list of 16 toys that were worth every penny of your allowance and made all those weeks of waiting feel like nothing.

1. Game Boy Color

The Game Boy Color was the ultimate allowance goal, opening the door to iconic games like Pokémon Red and Blue and Super Mario Bros. Deluxe. With its pixelated graphics and just-enough color, this handheld console was revolutionary. Hours flew by as you leveled up your Pokémon, beat your high scores, or just enjoyed some solo gaming bliss. It was the ultimate reward for all those chores.

2. Furby

Ah, Furby—the adorable, slightly creepy, big-eyed owl-like creature that talked, blinked, and seemingly developed a mind of its own. Furbies were one of the hottest toys of their time, and you could spend hours “teaching” yours new words (even if it mostly made strange sounds). Whether you loved it or were a little freaked out by it, a Furby was definitely worth the hype.

3. LEGO Sets

Whether you were building pirate ships, Star Wars spacecraft, or entire cities, LEGO sets offered endless possibilities for creativity. They weren’t cheap, so it took dedication to save up for that dream set. But once you had it, the hours spent building, rebuilding, and letting your imagination run wild made it worth every single penny (and painful step on a stray brick).

4. Polly Pocket

Polly Pocket’s miniature worlds could fit right in your pocket, making it perfect for on-the-go play. These tiny, colorful compacts housed entire little universes, complete with rooms, accessories, and of course, Polly and her friends. You could carry them everywhere, and each one was like a secret little escape. For mini-adventure lovers, saving up for a Polly Pocket was a no-brainer.

5. Tamagotchi

Taking care of a virtual pet was surprisingly intense, but Tamagotchis were the ultimate test of responsibility. Feeding, playing with, and cleaning up after your digital friend was a round-the-clock commitment that felt deeply rewarding. Owning a Tamagotchi meant carrying your tiny “pet” everywhere and keeping it alive was a point of pride—or frustration if it didn’t go as planned.

6. Hot Wheels Tracks

Hot Wheels weren’t just about the cars—they were about the tracks. From loops to launchers, a Hot Wheels track let you send those tiny cars flying across the room in epic races. Saving up for a new track or an expansion was always worth it, and each one added a new level of speed, stunts, and excitement to your collection. Nothing beat watching your favorite car nail the perfect loop.

7. Easy-Bake Oven

Image Credit: Bradross63 – Own work/CC BY-SA 4.0/Wiki Commons

For kids who loved to play chef, the Easy-Bake Oven made tiny, delicious (ish) treats with a just little heat and a lot of patience. Nothing beat the thrill of “baking” a mini cake or brownie and sharing it proudly (even if it tasted like pure sugar). The Easy-Bake Oven made every allowance dollar feel like an investment in culinary greatness.

8. Beyblades

“Let it rip!” Beyblades transformed any flat surface into an arena where these spinning tops could duke it out. Beyblade battles were fast, furious, and incredibly satisfying as you watched your chosen top clash with others in a whirl of plastic and metal. Every Beyblade had its own personality, making it exciting to save up for new models and compete with friends.

9. American Girl Dolls

Image Credit: Jeff Sandquist/CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons

If you saved up for an American Girl Doll, you knew you were getting something special. These dolls were so much more than toys—they each had a backstory, outfits, and even books to accompany their lives. Owning one meant having a friend with a story as complex as any novel, and each doll felt like a lifelong investment.

10. Nerf Guns

Image Credit: Stephen Ayotte/Public Domain/Wiki Commons

Nerf guns turned the backyard into a full-blown battlefield, with foam darts flying everywhere. Whether you were playing capture the flag or staging a full-scale ambush, a good Nerf blaster was key to any game plan. Saving up for one of the bigger, cooler models with extra ammo storage made every dart feel like an investment in future victories.

11. Bratz Dolls

Image Credit: Timo Tervo/CC BY-SA 2.0/Wiki Commons

With their bold fashion and oversized eyes, Bratz dolls were a fierce alternative to traditional dolls. Each one had a unique style, and mixing and matching their accessories made every playtime a mini fashion show. Saving up for that perfect Bratz doll wasn’t just a toy purchase—it was an introduction to fashion, confidence, and embracing your inner diva.

12. Yu-Gi-Oh! and Pokémon Cards

Image Credit: Stéphane Gallay/CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons

Trading cards were the ultimate schoolyard currency, and every new pack held the possibility of finding a rare, game-changing card. Whether you were building a battle-ready deck or just collecting your favorites, each new card pack was a thrill. They made every allowance feel like a ticket to adventure, and the excitement of scoring a rare holographic card was unmatched.

13. Scooters

The classic Razor scooter transformed sidewalks into race tracks, and every kid who had one felt like they were in the coolest club. Mastering the art of the scooter, complete with tricks and high-speed races, made every penny spent on it feel like pure joy. Scooters were as practical as they were fun, and they stayed in style for years.

14. Skip-It

Image Credit: Saskatoon Public Library/CC BY 2.0/Wiki Commons

Skip-It was the one time kids voluntarily added cardio to their routine. You’d attach it to one ankle, spin it around, and try to jump over the loop as it passed. The built-in counter meant you could track your high scores, making it as competitive as it was addictive. Saving up for a Skip-It brought endless fun and some serious calf workouts.

15. Magic 8 Ball

The Magic 8 Ball turned every question into a mysterious, suspenseful moment, delivering “Yes,” “No,” or “Ask Again Later” with a shake. It was part fortune-teller, part best friend, and every kid with one knew that the answer you got was pretty much law. For just a few bucks, the Magic 8 Ball became the ultimate source of amusement and “guidance.”

16. Super Soakers

The bigger, the better—that was the motto for Super Soakers. These water blasters turned every summer day into a water war, and the joy of saving up for a model with extra power was unmatched. Running around with a Super Soaker felt like being armed with the ultimate summer tool. If you had a good one, you were guaranteed to rule any backyard battle.

Like our content? Be sure to follow us!