18 Collectibles You Wish You’d Never Given Away
Ever look at your shelf and feel a twinge of regret for that thing you let go? Maybe it was an old toy, a limited-edition trinket, or something you thought you’d outgrown. But as the saying goes, one person’s junk is another person’s wildly expensive auction find. If you’ve ever wished you could hop in a time machine to reclaim a piece of your childhood, you’re not alone. Let’s revisit 18 of those collectibles that make you cringe just thinking about how much they’re worth now.
1. Beanie Babies – The Great Fleece Scandal
Remember when you had an entire zoo of Beanie Babies? And you swore you were going to retire early off them? Little did you know the market for polyester animals would collapse faster than your faith in ‘90s fashion. Today, a rare one like “Princess Diana Bear” might fetch a small fortune, but alas, yours are probably gathering dust in someone else’s attic.
2. Pokémon Cards – Gotta Regret ‘Em All
Who knew that tiny pieces of cardboard featuring cartoon creatures could someday pay for a vacation? First-edition Charizard cards have been selling for as much as a used car. Meanwhile, your collection was either traded for lunch snacks or vanished into thin air when your mom did a “cleaning sweep.”
3. Star Wars Action Figures – The Force Was Not With You
Those tiny plastic Luke Skywalkers and Darth Vaders? Turns out they’re worth way more than the pretend battles you staged between them. While you were busy pretending to blow up the Death Star, other kids were stashing their figures in mint-condition boxes. Now, those collectors are cruising in Millennium Falcon-shaped yachts, and you’re here, missing your lightsaber.
4. Comic Books – Pages of Pity
You thought flipping through your comics was fun until you realized the value of a pristine, untouched edition. That copy of Amazing Fantasy #15 (the first appearance of Spider-Man) could pay off student loans today. Too bad yours has ketchup stains and dog-eared corners because little you thought comics were for reading. Silly past self.
Follow us for more of these articles.
5. Game Boy – A Game of Regret
Remember your Game Boy? The endless hours of Tetris, Mario, and frustration when the batteries died mid-level? Fast-forward to today, and collectors are willing to fork over a nice chunk of change for the original models in good condition. Sadly, yours probably met an untimely end in the bottom of a drawer, where old electronics go to die.
6. Vintage Barbie Dolls – A Plastic Gold Mine
You may have spent hours brushing her hair and styling those tiny outfits, but your vintage Barbie had greater potential as a financial advisor. Some rare Barbie dolls can fetch thousands, yet yours likely took a detour into a garage sale for a quick buck. Barbie’s dream house? More like your lost retirement dream.
Follow us for more of these articles.
7. Hot Wheels – Burnt Rubber, Lost Fortune
Those little cars you sent racing down plastic tracks? Some of them are worth more now than the actual car in your driveway. Hot Wheels from the ’60s and ’70s are prime collector’s items, with rare editions selling for thousands. While you were busy crashing them into walls, collectors were revving their engines towards a small fortune.
8. Magic: The Gathering Cards – The Magic That Slipped Away
Before Pokémon took over your card obsession, there was Magic: The Gathering. If you had a Black Lotus card and let it go, take a moment to mourn. That little piece of cardboard now fetches six figures in pristine condition. You probably traded it for a Slurpee and a pack of gum. Genius move, right?
Follow us for more of these articles.
9. McDonald’s Happy Meal Toys – Not So Happy Now
You begged your parents for a Happy Meal just to get your hands on those toys. Sure, they seemed like plastic junk at the time, but some are now worth more than the actual meal itself. That limited-edition Disney toy you tossed? Let’s just say it would’ve bought a lot of Big Macs today.
10. VHS Tapes – Be Kind, Rewind Your Regrets
VHS tapes might seem like the fossilized remains of a prehistoric era, but some rare ones are worth a surprising amount. If you ever owned an original Beauty and the Beast or The Lion King on VHS, you might have tossed away a small windfall. Sadly, most of them now sit unloved in landfills next to broken VCRs.
Follow us for more of these articles.
11. Lego Sets – Blocked Your Fortune
All those Lego sets you built, dismantled, and inevitably stepped on barefoot? If you kept the pieces together and the box intact, those sets could now be worth a small fortune. Star Wars and Harry Potter-themed Legos especially can command high prices. But, knowing most people, your Legos are probably lost somewhere in the void under your couch.
12. Sports Cards – Missed Home Runs
Baseball, basketball, football—if you had sports cards as a kid, you were holding onto a potential gold mine. Rookie cards, in particular, are worth big bucks today. But, like many, your collection probably ended up in a shoebox that mysteriously disappeared the same week your dad cleaned the garage.
Follow us for more of these articles.
13. Furby – The Creepy Cash Cow
Furby was equal parts toy and potential nightmare fuel, but collectors today are eager to pay up for these creatures. The limited-edition ones are worth hundreds, sometimes thousands. So, next time you wonder what happened to your old Furby, just imagine it haunting someone else’s bank account now.
14. Tamagotchi – Digital Pet, Real Regret
Remember your virtual pet that you swore you’d never abandon, only for it to “die” because you forgot to feed it? Tamagotchis were all the rage in the late ’90s and early 2000s, and first editions are now collector’s items. The next time your phone battery dies, just think about how much more you’d care if it were a Tamagotchi.
Follow us for more of these articles.
15. My Little Pony – Galloping Away With Your Money
If you were a fan of My Little Pony, you might be surprised to know that some of those pastel-colored ponies are now worth quite a bit. The first-generation ponies from the ‘80s, in particular, can fetch a hefty price. But instead of keeping them for nostalgia (or investment), you likely handed them off to a younger cousin who never called back.
16. Nintendo 64 – Game Over, Wallet
The Nintendo 64 was a game-changing console (literally), and original models in good condition are highly sought after. Not to mention, games like Super Mario 64 and The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time are considered classics and can go for a pretty penny. Too bad yours ended up in the basement of your parents’ house… or worse, a yard sale.
Follow us for more of these articles.
17. Transformers – More Than Meets the Value
Those action figures that transformed from robots into vehicles? Yeah, they transformed into cash, too. First-generation Transformers toys can be worth a small fortune, but like many, you probably wore out the joints from all that transforming. Now, someone else is cashing in on the nostalgia while you reminisce about Optimus Prime’s glory days.
18. PEZ Dispensers – Sweet, Sweet Missed Opportunity
PEZ dispensers were more than just candy holders—they’re now collectible treasures. Some of the rarest dispensers, like vintage Mickey Mouse or superhero editions, are worth hundreds, if not thousands. If only you hadn’t popped the heads off to get to the candy faster. Now you’re left with sticky memories and a pile of lost opportunities.
Like our content? Be sure to follow us!
